Guarantees and international standards
The principle of debido proceso constitutes a fundamental guarantee recognized by the National Constitution and international human rights treaties with constitutional hierarchy. In the sphere of derecho aduanero, its application acquires particular relevance due to the intensity of State control and the legal and economic consequences that may arise from administrative proceedings.
The analysis of due process in Argentine customs procedures requires consideration of both the domestic legal framework and the estándares internacionales applicable international standards, in particular those derived from international human rights law and the multilateral trading system.
Due process as a constitutional guarantee
The National Constitution provides that no one may be deprived of their rights without prior legal proceedings grounded in law. This principle, which extends to the administrative sphere, implies that any action by the customs authority must respect a set of minimum guarantees intended to ensure the legality, reasonableness, and legitimacy of the procedure.
In this regard, due process operates as a limit on the exercise of administrative powers and as an essential guarantee against decisions that may affect the subjective rights or legitimate interests of regulated parties.
Application of due process in customs proceedings
Customs proceedings present particular features that justify a specific analysis of the scope of due process. Among them, the following stand out:
- The breadth of the supervisory and control powers of the customs authority,
- The technical complexity of foreign trade operations,
- And the possible imposition of administrative and economic sanctions.
These characteristics reinforce the need to ensure a procedure that fully respects constitutional and legal guarantees.
Main procedural guarantees involved
Among the guarantees that make up due process in customs matters, the following may be mentioned:
Right to defense
The regulated party must have an effective opportunity to be informed of the charges brought, access the case file, offer and produce evidence, and submit such defenses as it deems appropriate before a final decision is adopted.
Principle of legality
The actions of the administration must be based on existing laws and applied in a reasonable and proportional manner, avoiding arbitrary or expansive interpretations that may prejudice the regulated party.
Reasoned grounds for administrative acts
Acts issued within the framework of customs proceedings must be duly reasoned, expressly setting out the facts, the evidence, and the legal provisions on which they are based.
Reasonable time frame
The procedure must be conducted within a reasonable timeframe, avoiding undue delays that may affect legal certainty and the normal conduct of commercial activities.
Applicable international standards
The analysis of due process in customs matters cannot disregard the estándares internacionales. The analysis of due process in customs matters cannot disregard international standards. Human rights treaties, as well as the principles recognized within the framework of the World Trade Organization, establish minimum parameters that States must respect in their administrative procedures.
These standards reinforce the requirement for transparent, predictable procedures that respect the right of defense, and constitute a relevant guide for the interpretation and application of domestic customs law.
Final considerations
Respect for due process in customs procedures constitutes a central element for ensuring the legality of administrative actions and the protection of the rights of foreign trade operators.
Its proper application helps to strengthen legal certainty, system predictability, and confidence in the institutions responsible for customs control, in line with the commitments undertaken by the Argentine Republic at the constitutional and international levels.
📄 Academic paper
Web version of the paper
“Due process in Argentine customs procedures: guarantees and international standards”
👉 Download the complete paper in PDF
Related advisory services
For more information on legal advisory services in Customs Law and Foreign Trade, and on the defense of rights and guarantees in proceedings before the customs authority, you may consult our specialized practice area.